“Wine verses” on khums of the 12th century from the settlement of Shodmalik-ota

Authors

  • Bakhtiyar Babadjanov National Center for Archaeology of the Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Uzbekistan; R.B. Suleimenov Institute of Oriental Studies of the Committee of Science of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan https://orcid.org/0009-0001-6718-9819
  • Saida Ilyasova National Center for Archaeology of the Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Uzbekistan https://orcid.org/0009-0004-6716-6029

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.52967/akz2024.1.23.288.304

Keywords:

Settlement of Shodmalik-ota, khums, wine poetry, Nasir-i Khisrav, Sufism, the ideology of a medieval city, wine-making workshops

Abstract

Arabographic inscriptions on large ceramic dishes of the Muslim period have not yet been found and have not been published, except for a few cases with manufacturers' stamps. In this article, for the first time in Central Asian archaeology, the texts on the rims of three khums of the second half of the 12th century, found in different years at the site of Shodmalik-ota (Tashkent region), are studied and interpreted. All inscriptions belong to the genre of the so-called "wine poetry". The authors suggested reading and translating these poems with the necessary comments, as well as analyzing the texts from the point of view of the ideology of the handicraft "settlement" of the pre-Mongolian city, a topic that rarely becomes the subject of research. The authors focus on two main questions: is it possible to interpret these ruba‘i “directly”, that is, as an open chanting of wine as a “healer of the soul”, despite religious restrictions? Or should these verses be considered in a metaphorical sense, as a consequence of the influence of the ideology of Sufism, in which the genres of "wine poetry" acquired a figurative meaning, changing the semantics of descriptions of a drunken state as a "response of the soul" to the knowledge of the True (God)? There is no preference for one or another interpretation in the article, and the authors believe that one did not exclude the other, referring to a number of archaeological finds of wine presses in Central Asia during the era of the “Muslim Renaissance”, as well as reports from a number of sources indicating that the consumption of wine remained a “hidden tradition” in different strata of society, despite religious restrictions.

References

Abu-l-Faradj al-Isfahani. 1980. Kniga pesen / Per. s arabskogo A.B. Halidova, B.Ya. Shidfar (Abu-l-Faraj al-Isfahani. Book of Songs / Translated from Arabic by A.B. Khalidova, B.Ya. Shidfar). Moscow: “Glavnaya redakciya vostochnoi literatury” Publ. (in Russian).

Amir Mu‘izzi – Amir Abu Abdullah Muhammad ibn Abdul-Malik Muizzi Nishapuri. 2016. In: Persian-Literature. (Library of Persian Literature "Ganjoor"). URL: https://ganjoor.net/amir/ghasa/sh319(accessed: 06/10/2023) (in Persian).

Babadjanov, B. M. 2010. Kokandskoe hanstvo: vlast, politika, religiya (Kokand Khanate: Power, Politics, Religion). Tashkent: "Yangi nashr" Publ. (in Russian).

Bernshtam, A. N. 1948. In: Epigrafika Vostoka (Epigraphy of the East), II, 107-113 (in Russian).

Bernshtam, A. N. 1950. In: Materialy i issledovaniya po arheologii SSSR (Materials and research on the archaeology of the USSR), 14, 1-160 (in Russian).

Dehlavi – Amiir Hosrov Dehleví. 1996. Ghazals. In: Persian-Literature. (Library of Persian Literature "Ganjoor"). URL: https://ganjoor.net/khosro/gozide/ghazalamkh/sh1720 (accessed: 06/10/2023) (in Persian).

Ilyasova, S. R. 2021a. In: Arheologiya Uzbekistana (Archaeology of Uzbekistan), 1 (24), 33-41 (in Russian).

Ilyasova, S. R. 2021b. In: Smagulovskiy sbornik. Specialnyi vypusk Vestnika Mejdunarodnogo Instituta Tsentralnoaziatskih issledovaniy (Collection of articles in honor of Smagulov. Special issue of the “Bulletin of the International Institute for Central Asian Studies”), 32, 53-61 (in Russian).

Ilyasova, S. R., Ilyasov, Dj. Y., Imamberdyev, R. A., Ishakova, E. A. 2016. «Net blaga v bogatstve …». Glazurovannaya keramika Tashkentskogo oazisa IX–XII vekov (“There is no good in wealth ...”. Glazed Ceramics of the Tashkent Oasis of the 9th–12th centuries). Moscow: “Marjani Foundation” Publ. (in Russian).

Klein, L. S. 2011. Istoriya arheologicheskoy mysli (History of archaeological thought). Vol. 2. Saint Petersburg: Saint Petersburg University (in Russian).

Qoshghariy, Mahmud. 1962. Turkiy so’zlar devoni (Devoni lughatit turk). Uch tomlik. II tom. S. Mutalibov tarjimasi va nashri (Dictionary of Turkish words. Three volumes. Volume II. Translated and published by S. Mutalibov). Tashkent: “Uz FA nashriyoti” Publ. (in Uzbek).

Livshits, V. A. 2008. Sogdiiskaya epigrafika Srednei Azii i Semirech'ya (The Sogdian Epigraphy in Central Asia and Semirech’e). St. Petersburg: Faculty of Philology, St. Petersburg State University (in Russian).

Lunina, S. B. 1984. Goroda Yujnogo Sogda v VIII–XII vv. (Cities of Southern Sogd in the 8th–12th centuries). Tashkent: “Fan” Publ. (in Russian).

Marshak, B. I. 1976. In: Iskusstvo i arheologiya Irana (Art and archaeology of Iran), II, 148-173 (in Russian).

Minasyants V.S., Alpatkina T.G. 2014. T. M. Mirgiyazov is a little-known name in Central Asian archeology. Tashkent: “Uz FA nashriyoti” Publ. (in Russian).

Reysner, M. L. 2010. In: Porhomovskiy, V. Y., Semenyuk, N. N. (eds.). Kulturno-istoricheskaya paradigma i yazykovye protsess (Cultural-historical paradigm and language processes), 91-127 (in Russian).

Reysner, M. L. 2015. Persidskaya religiozno-misticheskaya poeziya XI–XV vv. Uchebnoe posobie (Persian Religious and Mystical Poetry of the 11th–15th centuries. Study guide). Kazan: Kazan federal university (in Russian).

Reysner, M. L., Chalisova, N. Y. 2007. In: Matyushina, I. G., Neklyudov, S. Y. (eds.). “Lirika: genezis i evolyuciya” (Lyrics: genesis and evolution). Moscow: Russian State University for the Humanities, 175-231 (in Russian).

Rudaki. 1998. Mother of wine (مادر مي) In: Persian-Literature. (Library of Persian Literature "Ganjoor"). URL: https://ganjoor.net/roodaki/baghimande/sh89 (accessed: 05/10/2023) (in Persian).

As-Suli, Abu Bakr Muhammad. 1998. Kitab al-avrak. Kriticheskii tekst i per. na russkiy yazyk V.I. Belyaeva i A.B. Halidova; Predislovie, primechanie i ukazateli A.B. Halidova (As-Suli, Abu Bakr Muhammad. Kitab al-awraq. Critical text and transl. into Russian V.I. Belyaev and A.B. Khalidov; Foreword, note and indexes by A.B. Khalidov). St. Petersburg: “Peterburgskoe vostokovedenie” Publ. (in Russian).

Firdousi. 1993. Shahname. Izdateli: C.B. Lahuti, A. Lahuti, A.A. Starikov. Perevod C.B. Lahuti (Ferdawsi. Shahname. Publishers: Ts.B. Lakhuti, A. Lakhuti, A.A. Starikov. Transl. by C.B. Lahuti). Vol. I. Moscow: “Ladomir” Publ. (in Russian).

Haqani – Afzal ad-din Badil Ibrahim ibn Ali. 2016. Ghazals. In: Persian-Literature. (Library of Persian Literature "Ganjoor"). URL: https://ganjoor.net/khaghani/divankh/ghasidekh/sh200 (accessed: 06/10/2023) (in Persian).

Chalisova, N. Y. 2011. In: Vestnik Rossiyskogo gosudarstvennogo gumanitarnogo universiteta (Bulletin of the Russian State Humanitarian University), 2, 126-157 (in Russian).

Shishkin, V. A. 1940. In: Izvestiya Uzbekistanskogo filiala Akademii nauk SSSR (News of the Uzbekistan branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences), 8, 56–61 (in Russian)

De la Vaissière, Étienne. 2010. In: Turcica, 42, 267-278 (in French).

Dhabhar, B. N. 1955 In: Essays on Iranian Subjects. Bombay, 181–195 (in English).

Hanaway, W. L. 1988. In: Iran, 26, 69–80. (in English).

Hodder, Ian & Hutson, Scott. 2003. Reading the past. Current approaches to interpretation in archaeology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press (3rd edn) (in English).

Ghouchani, A. 1999. In: Bulletin of the Asia Institute. New Series, 13, 141-150 (in English).

Meisami, J. S. 2003. Structure and Meaning in Medieval Arabic and Persian Poetry. London: Routledge Curzon (in English).

Published

2024-03-31

How to Cite

Babadjanov Б. М., & Ilyasova С. Р. (2024). “Wine verses” on khums of the 12th century from the settlement of Shodmalik-ota. Kazakhstan Archeology, (1 (23), 288–304. https://doi.org/10.52967/akz2024.1.23.288.304

Issue

Section

Interdisciplinary research